Overview
A guide that will help you with all complex pizza recipes in game!
✨Before you browse✨
• The following contents contain references from the Good Pizza, Great Pizza fandom. [good-pizza-great-pizza.fandom.com] 💙
• To quickly find what you’re looking for, press ctrl + F and type in pizza keywords (e.g: lactose intolerant, salty sailor, supreme, etc.)
• If you are only looking for all pizza recipes in Good Pizza, Great Pizza, I have them all compiled in another guide! Click here.
1 • Variable pizzas
For recipes in this section, simply use whatever ingredients that are available and don’t worry about the others!
No.
Pizza
Recipe
1
Vegan
Sauce + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
2
Vegetarian
Sauce + Cheese + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
3
All-Dressed Pizza
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Bacon + Pineapple + Anchovy + Ham + Basil + Shrimp + Corn + Chicken
4
Whole wheat works
Wheat Dough + Sauce + Cheese + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
5
Pescatarian
Sauce + Cheese + Olive + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Anchovy + Mushroom + Shrimp
6
Heat sweet wheat
Wheat Dough + Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Anchovy + Ham + Shrimp + Chicken
7
Meat and cheese
2 variations:
• No fish: Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham + Chicken + Shrimp
• No seafood: Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham + Chicken
• No fish: Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham + Chicken + Shrimp
• No seafood: Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham + Chicken
8
Half meat, half Vegetarian
Sauce + Cheese
• On one half: Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Anchovy + Ham+ Shrimp + Chicken
• On the other half: Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
• On one half: Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Anchovy + Ham+ Shrimp + Chicken
• On the other half: Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
9
Half fruit and fungus, half meat and cheese
Sauce + Cheese
• On one half: Mushroom + Olive + Bell Pepper + Pineapple
• On the other half: Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Anchovy + Ham + Shrimp + Chicken
• On one half: Mushroom + Olive + Bell Pepper + Pineapple
• On the other half: Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Anchovy + Ham + Shrimp + Chicken
10
Half fruit and fungus and half meat
Sauce + Cheese
• On one half: Mushroom + Olive + Bell Pepper + Pineapple
• On the other half: Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Anchovy + Ham + Shrimp + Chicken
• On one half: Mushroom + Olive + Bell Pepper + Pineapple
• On the other half: Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Anchovy + Ham + Shrimp + Chicken
11
One with fruits, one veggies and sauce, one meat and cheese
3 pizzas:
• Sauce + Cheese + Olive + Bell Pepper + Pineapple
• Sauce + Onion + Basil + Corn
• Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Anchovy + Ham + Shrimp + Chicken
• Sauce + Cheese + Olive + Bell Pepper + Pineapple
• Sauce + Onion + Basil + Corn
• Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Anchovy + Ham + Shrimp + Chicken
12
Lactose intolerant
Sauce + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Bacon + Pineapple + Anchovy + Ham + Basil + Shrimp + Corn + Chicken
2 • Named pizzas
No.
Pizza
Recipe
1
Supreme Pizza
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper
2
Classic Meat
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage
3
Meat Lover’s
2 variations:
• Red sauce only: Tomato Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham
• With olives: Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Olive + Bacon + Ham
• Red sauce only: Tomato Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham
• With olives: Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Olive + Bacon + Ham
4
Pork Pie
Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham
5
Flammkuchen Pizza
Cheese + Onion + Bacon
6
Hawaiian Pizza
2 variations:
• Normal: Sauce + Cheese + Ham + Pineapple
• With shrimps: Sauce + Cheese + Shrimps + Pineapple
• Normal: Sauce + Cheese + Ham + Pineapple
• With shrimps: Sauce + Cheese + Shrimps + Pineapple
7
Salty Sailor
Sauce + Cheese + Olive + Anchovy
8
Stinky Pete
Sauce + Cheese + Onion + Anchovy
9
Fruity Pig
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Olive + Bell Pepper + Bacon + Pineapple + Ham
10
Half Salty Sailor, half Fruity Pig
Sauce + Cheese + Olive
• On one half: Anchovy
• On the other half: Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Pineapple + Ham
• On one half: Anchovy
• On the other half: Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Pineapple + Ham
11
Green Dream
Sauce + Cheese + Bell Pepper + Basil
12
Breakfast Pizza
Sauce + Cheese + Sausage + Mushroom + Onion + Bacon + Ham
13
Joker Pizza
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Bell Pepper + Eggplant
3 • Characters
Picture wall
No.
Character
Dialog
Recipe
1
Albert Einstein
“For my order you must solve this formula: E = mc2”
[Cheese + Mushroom] x 2
2
Christopher Columbus
“I’m a long way from home. Can I get a salami pizza?”
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni
3
Edgar Allan Poe
“My pet raven has a mostly meat diet. Can I get a meat lover’s pizza without seafood?”
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham + Chicken
4
Elon Musk
“I’ve got green in my pocket, but I need them in my body too. Can I get a pizza with green toppings? Toast it up with a flamethrower.”
Sauce + Cheese + Bell Pepper + Basil
5
Elvis Presley
“Can I get a peanut butter, banana and bacon pie? It’s okay if you don’t have the bananas and spread.”
Sauce + Cheese + Bacon
6
Marilyn Monroe
“I’m just a small girl in a big world looking for something to eat. Can I get a veggie pizza without cheese.”
Sauce + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
7
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
“One pizza with salami. Because sometimes, the best things are the classics.”
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni
Other characters
No.
Character
Dialog
Ingredients
1
Fireman
“I want pizza, but I can’t be sluggish on the job.”
Sauce + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Basil
“I’ll have a fire-alarm meat lover’s. I love it when my mouth’s on fire!”
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bell Pepper + Bacon + Ham + Chicken
2
Invisible Man
“I want a pizza with invisible toppings, just like me!”
Sauce + Cheese
“Wonder how I’m like this? Make me the perfect pepperoni pizza, and I’ll tell you!”
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni
“If you like my invisibility trick, then how about a pescatarian pie as a reward? But make the pineapple disappear.”
Sauce + Cheese + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Anchovy + Basil + Shrimp + Corn
“I’ve been into card tricks lately. Gimme a pizza with red pepperoni on one half, black olives on the other!”
Sauce + Cheese
• On one half: Olive
• On the other half: Pepperoni
• On one half: Olive
• On the other half: Pepperoni
“A cheese pizza, then M is the magic letter!”
Sauce + Cheese + Mushroom + Ham + Shrimp
3
Kimmy Slice
“Cheesy peasy! Okay… Give me a pepperoni pizza with 16 slices.”
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni
4
Math Student
“I’m here for tutuoring. I need one half of four pepperoni pizzas to help with my math homework.”
[Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni] x2
“My math midterm is today, and I need to learn about fractions! I need one-fourth of two pizzas to be basil and the three-fourths to be anchovies.”
2 pizzas:
• Sauce + Cheese + Anchovy
• Sauce + Cheese + Anchovy + Basil on one half
• Sauce + Cheese + Anchovy
• Sauce + Cheese + Anchovy + Basil on one half
“It’s time for my math final! I need the one-third of a dozen pizzas divided by two. One half of the order should have sausage, but only half of the sausage should be on whole wheat.”
2 pizzas:
• Wheat dough + Sauce + Cheese + Sausage on one half
• Sauce + Cheese + Sausage on one half
• Wheat dough + Sauce + Cheese + Sausage on one half
• Sauce + Cheese + Sausage on one half
5
Poet
“I saw you on the news
That you make great pizza
I’m in need of a muse
It’s a pleasure to meetcha
I’ll start simple if you please,
A plain pie with sauce and cheese”
That you make great pizza
I’m in need of a muse
It’s a pleasure to meetcha
I’ll start simple if you please,
A plain pie with sauce and cheese”
Sauce + Cheese
“The siren scent of sauce entices
Pepperoni and cheese in equal slices”
Pepperoni and cheese in equal slices”
Sauce + Cheese
• On one half: Pepperoni
• On one half: Pepperoni
“I’m here with a friend who wants to try every ingredient
But leave off the cheese; she’s lactose intolerant.”
But leave off the cheese; she’s lactose intolerant.”
Sauce + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Bacon + Pineapple + Anchovy + Ham + Basil + Shrimp + Corn + Chicken
“I’m on a date with an interesting guy;
He’s on a vegan diet.
But I’m also interested in your four pork pie,
And I would like to try it.”
He’s on a vegan diet.
But I’m also interested in your four pork pie,
And I would like to try it.”
Sauce
• On one half: Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham
• On the other half: Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
• On one half: Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham
• On the other half: Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
5
World Traveler/Carmen Sandiego
“I’ve got exotic tastes. Think you can make me a Thai chicken pizza?”
Sauce + Cheese + Onion + Basil + Chicken
“Okay, how bout a classic Greek pizza? You’ve gotta make that, right?”
Sauce + Cheese + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Basil
“This may be a long stretch, but do you guys make flammkuchen pizzas?”
Cheese + Onion + Bacon
“I highly doubt you make pissaladiére, but major props if you do!”
Olive + Onion + Anchovy
6
Dracula
“My favorite things to eat are… red. Think you can help me out?”
Sauce + Pepperoni + Bacon + Ham + Shrimp
“I’m on a new diet. Give me a mushroom-pepper pizza, but each gets their own half.”
Sauce + Cheese
• On one half: Mushroom
• On the other half: Bell pepper on one half
• On one half: Mushroom
• On the other half: Bell pepper on one half
“I don’t usually do vegetables, but I’ll give them a try. But no onions!”
Sauce + Cheese + Basil + Corn
7
Weird Girl/Art Girl
You can choose to make whatever you want for her order
✨Chapter-specific recipes✨
The recipes below are separated by chapter, as they’re necessary for the story to progress
Chapter 1
No.
Recipe
Dialog
1
Sauce + Cheese
“That was rhetorical, pal. Let’s see you at least make a regular cheese. Just six slices with sauce and cheese.”
“Well that was obvious. Let’s see you make a cheese pizza. Just six slices with sauce and cheese.”
“Well that was obvious. Let’s see you make a cheese pizza. Just six slices with sauce and cheese.”
2
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni
“Let’s see a pepperoni then. And yes that comes with cheese and sauce, rookie. Six even slices. I don’t wanna see no baby slices.”
“Too late now! Cause I want a pepperoni. And yes that comes with cheese and sauce, rookie. Six even slices. I don’t wanna see no baby slices.”
“Too late now! Cause I want a pepperoni. And yes that comes with cheese and sauce, rookie. Six even slices. I don’t wanna see no baby slices.”
3
Sauce + Cheese
• On one half: Pepperoni
• On one half: Pepperoni
“At least you know how indecisive these people are! Let’s see how ya split those pizzas. Make a half cheese and half pepperoni.”
Chapter 2
No.
Recipe
Dialog
1
3 pizzas:
• Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage
• Sauce + Cheese + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper
• Sauce + Cheese
• Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage
• Sauce + Cheese + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper
• Sauce + Cheese
“Greetings to you popular pizza proprietor! Your prowess has piqued the palates of our organization: The Stewards of Scared Ingredients! You might have noticed our lodge across the street.”
2
Sauce + Olive + Bell Pepper + Pineapple
“If your pizzas are truly elite, prepare me a pie that’s totally sweet!”
3
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon
• On one half: Ham
• On one half: Ham
“Saddle up, buckaroo, I reckon you’ve slung your fair share of pies, but if’n you’re tough tootin’ enough for my trial, I’m gonna need to see a mighty meat pie.”
4
Sauce + Cheese
• On one half: Mushroom + Onion
• On the other half: Olive + Bell Pepper + Basil
• On one half: Mushroom + Onion
• On the other half: Olive + Bell Pepper + Basil
“Can you bring balance to the sauce? I seek a pizza of peace, respectful of mother earth and her bounty.”
5
Wheat Dough + Sauce + Cheese
“…” (goat ordering pizza)
6
• On one half: Sauce + Anchovy
• On the other half: Nothing
• On the other half: Nothing
“Some believe that your pizza was foretold by the saucesayers. I think there’s something fishy about you… and I want you to prove it.”
7
You can choose to make anything for them
“My partners report that you have passed all the trials, but the saucesayers foresaw a transcendent za.”
“Fair pizza prodigy, I have been sent to provide you the penultimate test of true pizza perfect. Your time has nearly come”
“Fair pizza prodigy, I have been sent to provide you the penultimate test of true pizza perfect. Your time has nearly come”
8
Wheat Dough + Sauce + Cheese
• On one half: Mushroom
• On the other half: Pineapple
• On one half: Mushroom
• On the other half: Pineapple
“Risen up from earth’s decay and sun’s radiant nectar required. Death’s repose cannot be savored without sweet slice of life. Two sides balanced and made whole.”
Chapter 3
Dr. Keh
No.
Recipe
Dialog
1
Sauce + Cheese + Shrimp
“So, this is the parlor that’s been trending on OrderUp. Fine, then let’s try something even a caveman couldn’t mess up: shrimp.”
2
2 pizzas:
• Sauce + Cheese + Corn
• Sauce + Cheese + Chicken
• Sauce + Cheese + Corn
• Sauce + Cheese + Chicken
“Then prove it. One pizza with chicken and one pizza with corn.”
“What’s the matter, don’t have two of the hottest ingredients to date? Or are you too chicken to make these pizzas?”
“What’s the matter, don’t have two of the hottest ingredients to date? Or are you too chicken to make these pizzas?”
3
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni
“That’s the only way you could have beaten me, it has to be! I demand you make me a pepperoni pizza!”
Cook-off judge
No.
Recipe
Dialog
1
Cheese + Sauce + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
“You’ve seen me before. Now, make my usual and let’s be done with this stupid competition.”
PizzaCon judges
No.
Recipe
Dialog
1
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni
“I just had the best pepperoni pizza I’ve ever had! So, how does yours stack up?”
2
[Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni] x3
“Get me three pepperoni pizzas as fast as you can! I’m late to a PizzaCon judge’s meeting!”
3
[Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Mushroom] x2
“Make me two pepperoni and mushroom pizzas, put them through the oven twice.”
4
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper
“What a neat restaurant! You definitely get points for aesthetics. Now, how’s your supreme pizza?”
5
Cheese + Onion + Bacon
“Let’s test how well you know pizza. Make me a flammkuchen.”
6
Olive + Onion + Anchovy
“I’ve lived in France for years. Let’s see how your pissaladière represents its origins.”
7
Sauce + Cheese + Pineapple + Ham
“Man, judging pizza all day is hard work. I want to take it easy tonight with a Hawaiian pizza.”
8
2 pizzas:
• Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper
• Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham on one half
• Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper
• Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Bacon + Ham on one half
“Let’s see how you multitask in the kitchen. One supreme, and a meat lover’s with ham on one half only.”
9
Sauce + Cheese + Basil
“I’m supposed to be off-duty for judging, but… How about you make me your best margherita pizza anyway?”
10
Sauce + Cheese + Anchovy + Shrimp
“Other competitors were really lacking in seafood options. So, what about you?”
11
Sauce + Cheese + Onion + Basil + Corn
“See this orange shirt? It means I’m a judge! Now, make me a pizza with veggies. Double baked.”
12
3 pizzas:
• Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Ham + Bacon
• Sauce + Cheese + Anchovy + Shrimp
• Sauce + Cheese + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
• Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Ham + Bacon
• Sauce + Cheese + Anchovy + Shrimp
• Sauce + Cheese + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
“How’s your variety? One meat lover’s, one vegetarian, and one seafood.”
13
• On one half: Sauce + Pepperoni
• On the other half: Cheese + Chicken
• On the other half: Cheese + Chicken
“A half-cheeseless pepperoni, half-sauceless chicken pizza to get my good graces.”
PizzaCon goers
No.
Recipe
Dialog
1
Plain Dough
“I wanted to cosplay for this convention. See everyone dressed up makes me regret not doing it…”
2
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage
“Oh man, I smelled this from down the block. I just have to try your pepperoni and sausage pizza!”
“Oh wow, my very first PizzaCon pizza! How about pepperoni and sausage??”
“Oh wow, my very first PizzaCon pizza! How about pepperoni and sausage??”
3
Sauce + Cheese + Sausage
“This all looks familiar… hold the phone, were you on TV this week??”
4
Sauce + Cheese + Mushroom
“I was really looking forward to seeing The Pizza Underground, but I heard they split up. Sad…”
5
Sauce + Cheese + Sausage + Onion
“Hey. If you let me charge my battery, I’ll get a sausage and onion pizza.”
6
Cheese + Bell Pepper
“I’m so tired of being in a tight, crowded room. This is so much better!”
7
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper
“My visit in this city has been supremely awesome! I want this pizza to be supreme, too!”
8
Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Ham + Bacon
“This place looks exactly like my favorite spot back home! But can you make a meat pie like they do?”
9
Sauce + Cheese
• On one half: Pineapple
• On the other half: Anchovy
• On one half: Pineapple
• On the other half: Anchovy
“I’ve always dreamed of going to PizzaCon… I can’t believe I’m here! This is so exciting!!”
10
Sauce + Cheese + Olive + Basil
“I love PizzaCon. Hearing new recipes, getting new cookware, seeing all those happy faces… I live for this!”
11
Sauce + Cheese + Basil
“Do you guys have WiFi? I need to sit down for a bit, but I’ll order a margherita!”
12
Sauce + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Basil + Corn
“Oh, I just love mom-and-pop businesses! I’ll take a vegan pizza to go, please.”
13
Wheat Dough + Sauce + Cheese + Corn
“I take the rumors I heard about this place with a grain of salt. So give me a pizza with grains.”
14
Sauce + Cheese + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Pineapple + Anchovy + Basil + Shrimp + Corn
“If you make me a decent pescatarian pie, I’ll totally check in here on Pie Chart!”
15
2 pizzas:
• Sauce + Cheese + Olive + Bell Pepper + Pineapple
• Sauce + Cheese + Onion + Basil + Corn
• Sauce + Cheese + Olive + Bell Pepper + Pineapple
• Sauce + Cheese + Onion + Basil + Corn
“If you make me a decent pescatarian pie, I’ll totally check in here on Pie Chart!”
16
2 pizzas:
• Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Bacon + Pineapple + Anchovy + Ham + Basil + Shrimp + Corn + Chicken
• Wheat Dough + Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Bacon + Pineapple + Anchovy + Ham + Basil + Shrimp + Corn + Chicken
• Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Bacon + Pineapple + Anchovy + Ham + Basil + Shrimp + Corn + Chicken
• Wheat Dough + Sauce + Cheese + Pepperoni + Sausage + Mushroom + Olive + Onion + Bell Pepper + Bacon + Pineapple + Anchovy + Ham + Basil + Shrimp + Corn + Chicken
“Whoa, I’m loving all the choices! I can’t decide… Just give me all of it, one on white and one on wheat!”
Final thoughts
Thank you for checking out my guide! If you couldn’t find what you were looking for, take a look at my other guide on all recipes in Good Pizza, Great Pizza here 🥰💙
What is your favourite recipe and customer in the game? Let me know in the comments below!