Plots - An orderly, flexible, resilient approach to planetary organization
Introduction
90% complete - If you have questions you would like me to address, please leave a comment.
After about a hundred hours of playing around with the systems added since I last played, I am feeling pretty good about this design. I have confirmed that with some minor tweaks, that a planet full of plots can have full planetary shield coverage, signal tower coverage, and battlefield analysis base coverage. That means any incursion can be met with a hail of missiles, and automatically repaired(sorta). Logistics bots can distribute ammo to the weapon systems, so that doesn't impact the plots at all. They also allow much better use of the 15 meter tropics, which I have been spending an inordinate amount of time on.
They have changed the algorithm that guide logistic drones to evenly distribute supplies along all routes. I had hoped they would, and that change makes this design so much more workable. You can be a lot more aggressive building things out.
I should wrap up endurance tests this month.
This guide is for experienced players who are looking for a high level organizational system. New players should go start a game and make a complete mess of things.
Added on to that is the additional risks or the game being in early access. What if the recipe's change? What new buildings are there going to be? What new mechanics are coming? Will everything I have built be useless?
Finally the developers have indicated that there will be combat, which implies that what you build can be knocked down. It is one thing to design a system that will run flawlessly forever, it is quite another task to design a system that will be resilient in the face of failures.
My system attempts to provide techniques to handle the following problem- Scalability - Manufacturing capability can be added throughout the game without requiring previous construction to be retrofitted or abandoned
- Flexibility - You can adapt to supply problems quickly
- Resilience - Layouts are designed to withstand failure, and it is easy to incorporate redundancy across a planet, a system, and the whole cluster
- Aesthetics - Manufacturing is neat, orderly, and symmetrical
- Compact - Make good use of your planetary real-estate
- Efficiency - I don't try to minimize power use, warp cores, sorters, belts, logistics stations...
- Speed - While this architecture can scale to generate however much of something you want, it may introduce delays that an optimal plan will not. In the long run resource buffers will smooth everything out, in the short run things will be slower than a meticulously crafted system.
- Gameplay - This just may not be why you play games like this. If you derive joy out of making a perfect clockwork factory, this is probably not for you.
- Everything you can build can be destroyed - The game already allow you to remove these items, I see no reason that they can't be removed against your will
- Stars and planets will not be destructible - There really isn't anything the game currently provides that I can think of to protect against this, so I am not going to try.
- Recipes will not change much - I think the impact on the player base will be too great, but it certainly is not impossible
- There will be new technologies and buildings - Combat demands it. Also they have hinted at other features that would require it.
MK VI Planetary Layout
The planet is divided into sections of constant width called tropics. The latitude where the tropic of a planet changes is called a "regression line". Tropics are divided into rows of "plots". Each plot is the same size in any row in any tropic, and a blueprint that will fill a plot will be able to fill any plot on the planet.
Plots are 20 grid spaces high, and 24 grid spaces wide, and the planet has 14 rows of plots, 7 per hemisphere. In total a planet can hold 456 plots.
At this size, plots can provide a significant amount of production, while being small and nimble enough to work around the geometry of the planet. There is no reason to not be able to exploit every resource on the planet, and still be able to use the remaining land area for factories.
Building compartmentalized factories at this scale is a good strategy to minimize losses. If all or part of a plot is destroyed, the system can dynamically rearrange supply chains to make sure down stream resources are provided for. Larger designs present larger risks of failure. Smaller designs would require planetary logistic stations, which would make the supply chain less responsive.
The rows must be placed at very specific latitudes, but it's not hard once you get used to it. The rows are completely independent of each other, you can choose to line the plots in columns, or not. The northern and southern hemisphere each have 7 rows. "above" the regression line means towards the poles.
I think each plot should perform exactly one recipe, and should use an interstellar logistic station to interact with rest of the cluster. If you feel the desire to chain recipes together inside a plot, go for it. If you want to use planetary logistic stations to force the local use of the plots production, go for it. If you want to join plots together to enable larger assemblies, go for it. I am not going to present any designs that do those things, because I don't think they are good ideas, but if you think you can make that work, go for it.
A design that strongly couples an input and output is more brittle. If the producer is destroyed, the consumer cannot get resources from anywhere else. If the consumer is destroyed, the producer will back up and be useless. I advocate a design of maximum flexibility of the supply chain
While it is possible to fill all 456 plots with factories, I do not recommend it. Resources that fall within the rows should be extracted and distributed using an ILS. The ILS will probably need to be in the center of a plot, to avoid interfering with other nearby ILSs. This often means that a vein site might take up more than one plot.
When all your planets are at the risk of being attacked, I don't think it makes sense to create sparsely populated extraction planets. It seems more sensible to try to use all the resources and space on a planet, and concentrate your defenses.
There may be small defensive buildings that can fit in gaps. You can also fill them with accumulators to help insulate your planet from power outages from sieges or the destruction of power generating buildings.
Plots Blueprints
Building that consume materials should be placed in plots. I try to keep the number of buildings per belt at a minimum, and the number of buildings per plot at a maximum. All designs with less than 3 inputs can use either an Interstellar logistic Station, or a Planetary Logistic Station. I think you should use an ILS everywhere once you unlock them. Since all outputs go to a logistic station, which sorts them for you, there is no need to have separate output lines per product.
Unless otherwise noted, I recommend using Mk 3 sorters and Mk 2 belts. For upgradeable factories (assemblers, smelters) I recommend using the most basic version.- Artificial Star - Generates 600 MW. An ILS filled with Antimatter Fuel Rods can run this plot for over 33 hours without additional fuel.
- Energy Exchanger - I treat energy exchangers as factories that generate full accumulators. The plot will work for the discharge mode, but I have never used it that way.
- Mini Fusion Plant - Generates 210 MW. An ILS filled with Deuteron Fuel Rods can run this plot for about 8 hours.
- Ray Receiver - The design is intended for critical photon production. It can be used for power with gravity lenses as well. If you want to use ray receiver without inputs and outputs, I suggest placing them in the 3-4 gap or at the poles.
- Thermal Power Plant - Generates 30.24 MW. The stockpile duration depends on the fuel used. Hyrdogen Fuel Rods are by the far the best option providing about 4 hours of power.
- The fractionator and refinery plots have clear tops and bottoms. The blueprints may need to be rotated depending on the hemisphere you are building in. My other designs should work in either hemisphere without rotation.
- X-Ray cracking requires two logistic stations, one to input oxygen and one to output it. I don't ever use X-Ray cracking, and I don't want to come up with a two plot design to cover the process. If you would like to submit one in the comments, I will add it to the guide.
TODO - 4 Input Assembler Plot
Other Blueprints (Under Construction)
This section if for blueprints that solve particular problems that don't fit into plots, or are useful before logistic stations are available.
Future Work
These are the remaining task I need to get done for the guide.
- Prove concept - Are plot actually more resilient to disruption during enemy attacks as compared to a system that maximizes production per ILS?
- Research early game plans - I spent a lot of time (probably about 100 hours) trying to work out an optimal plan to get to plots ASAP, under the assumption that combat would come in timed waves. I am hoping that I can rework this to be simpler and less stressful when working with the actual combat system.
- Determine how games changes impact my design - I have not played in ages, and there are a lot of changes to the game I have not considered.
- Develop optimal energy plots - I have been working under the assumption that maximizing production per watt is the best survival strategy. This requires fine tuning sorter and logistic stations for each recipe. I also really need to develop a testing methodology so I can compare my design versus a more conventional approach.
- Add designs for 5 cube research, 4 input assembler
- Polar region designs
Changelog
* 9/2/2021 - Added MK VI layout. Deprecated MK V layout.
* 9/1/2021 - Updating Future Work
* 7/23/2021 - Adding blueprint codes
* 7/19/2021 - Added more items to "Future Work"
* 7/2/2021 - Removed deprecated Smelter, Research, Fluid, Power and Atomic Layout sections.
* 7/2/2021 - Updated designs for 1 input smelter, and 3 input miniature particle collider
* 6/29/2021 - Removed the "Assembler Layouts" section, added design to the deprecated page.
* 6/29/2021 - Added "Changelog" and "Deprecated Design" sections
Status
*12/17/2023 - Combat has finally been added to the game, and I am finally in a place where I can validate if this system I started designing 2 and a half years ago actually works. The combat system is a bit different than what I expected, so I am trying to figure out exactly how I can test the efficacy of this design. I expect it will take several months to an in-depth review, but hopefully I can get some preliminary indications by the the end of 2023.
MK V Planetary layout (DEPRECATED)
Plots are designed to grow. Because each plot has space reserved for it, you can start with 1 factory and build with the knowledge that you can come back to add production as you need it. When you fill up your plot, you can start a new one. Planets can support 288 regular plots, 40 big plots, and 120 crunch plots.
- Plots eventually have a logistics station in the middle of them, but are designed to migrate from an earlier technology level with ease.
- "helper" stations allow those plot to deal with up to 6 inputs or outputs.
- I assume you will be able to place some sort of defensive barrier around your infrastructure. Plots allow for a compact design that it easier to defend than a spread out infrastructure. This compactness makes it vulnerable to attack from space. A bomb is sure to hit something. I am hoping that the large number of logistics stations will provide cover for squishier buildings, and hopefully can be used as a base for attack craft
- Equator and 9 degrees latitude (5 major grid lines from the equator) - Plots are 20x20 with a 5 space gap around each plot. Each row can accommodate 40 plots. Use 1 and 2 input assembler, matrix generation lab, oil refining, and 1 and 2 input chemical plants. Thermal and fusion power plants also fit here. Turbines, Solar Panels, and accumulator can fit in the gaps between plots. I like to keep every other plot in the center row unused, in case I need to put weapon systems around the equator.
- 18 degrees latitude (10 Major grid lines from the equator) - Plots are 22x22 with a helper station above them that takes the output. Each row can accommodate 40 plots. Nothing can fit in the gaps between the plots in the row nor between in the gaps above them, but turbines, solar panels and accumulators can fit in the gap below. Use 3 input assembler or chemical plants. 1 or 2 input plots can also be used if you ran out of space in 1A.
- 23 degrees latitude (3 major grid lines below first fault) - Plots are 20x15 with a helper station below them. Each row can accommodate 40 plots. Use 1 or 2 input assembler plots here, with the inputs supplied by the helper stations. This region has significant grid crunch issues, which limits the geometry of the plots. While 3 inputs plots are possible here, I like to leave two open slots in the logistic station.
- 28.5 degrees latitude (1st fault Line) - The output logistic stations from the row below butt into the space. What to do with the gaps between the 1st and 2nd plots lines will be broken out into a separate section.
- 37.5 degrees latitude (5 major grid lines above first fault) - Plots are 30x30 with a 10 space gap around each plot, and have an interstellar logistic stations. Each row can accommodate 20 plots. These plots are used for 1 input smelters. I may change my advice on this at some point, but right now smelters seem to be the best option.
- 50.25 degrees latitude (2 Major grid lines above the second fault) - Plots are 20x20 with a 5 space gap around each plot. Each row can accommodate 24 plots. Use the same plots you would at the equator.
- 59 degrees latitude (2 Major grid lines above the third fault) - Plots are 22x22 with a helper station above them that takes the output. Each row can accommodate 20 plots. Use the same plots you would at 18 latitude
- 64.5 degrees latitude (fourth fault) - Plots are 20x15 with a helper station below them. Each row can accommodate 20 plots. Use the same plots you would at 23 latitude
- Polar Region - At this points no longer become feasible. I will break out the polar region into a separate section.
Inside of the manufacturing zones I normally try to contain veins to a single plot. Having access to resources inside of your perimeter is probably a good idea.
Power provides an interesting problem. Obviously protecting you power supply is of paramount importance. If the enemy can blow it up, everything you built stops working. The obvious solutions are to over produce, and to physically distribute. Without a clear understanding of the threats the game may provide it is difficult to come up with any solution other than to diversify, and attempt to wholly contain the supply chain for power supply within your defensive borders. And outside of a lot of oil in the region, that does not seem feasible. For now I recommend a mix of everything. Burn hydrogen within the building region, place accumulators between plots, Turbines covering the upper and lower bounds of the planet... The only caveat would be, it you can compactly place power generation inside the building zone, do it.
Blueprints Overview (DEPRECATED)
Building that consume material should be placed in plots. I try to keep the number of buildings per belt at a minimum, and the number of buildings per plot at a maximum. All designs with less than 3 inputs can use either an Interstellar logistic Station, or a Planetary Logistic Station. I think you should use an ILS everywhere once you unlock them. Since all outputs go to a logistic station, which sorts them for you, there is no need to have separate output lines per product.
Unless otherwise noted, I recommend using Mk 3 sorters and belts. For upgradable factories (assemblers, smelters) I recommend using the most basic version.
- Standard - These plots can fit in the equatorial, 9 latitude, 18 latitude, 50.25 latitude and 59 latitude rows if a planetary logistic station is used. If an ILS station is used they can not be placed in the 18 and 59 latitude rows, but will still work in the other rows.
- ILS - These plots require and ILS and can only fit in the equatorial, 9 latitude, and 59 latitude rows.
- Helper - These plots can only fit in the 18 latitude or 59 latitude rows, and must use a planetary logistic station.
- Crunch - These plots can be used in the 23 latitude and 64.5 latitude rows.
- Big - These plots can be used in the 37.5 latitude rows.
1 Input Blueprints (DEPRECATED)
- Artificial Star - Generates 600 MW. An ILS filled with Antimatter Fuel Rods can run this plot for over 33 hours without additional fuel. Mk 1 sorters are optimal for this blueprint.
- Assembler - For now I recommend using the 2 input assembler blueprint for 1 input recipes. I may alter this recommendation based on the implementation of the blueprints feature
- Energy Exchanger - I treat energy exchangers as factories that generate full accumulators. The plot will work for the discharge mode, but I have never used it that way.
- Fractionator - This design is impacted by an issue that causes belts to move fewer than the full capacity of the belt. Deutrium generation is about 10% less than mathematically predicted, and the fractionators flash instead of producing a solid light. I don't know if this is a bug, or intended design, and I have not tested this since March 2021.
- Mini Fusion Plant - Generates 108 MW. An ILS filled with Deuteron Fuel Rods can run this plot for about 22.8 hours plus 3.5 hours per level of vertical construction. Mk 1 sorters are optimal for this blueprint.
- Ray Receiver - TODO
- Thermal Power Plant - Generates 26 MW. The stockpile duration depends on the fuel used. Hyrdogen Fuel Rods are by the far the best option providing about 8 hours of power plus 1.5 hours per level of vertical construction.
2 Input Blueprints (DEPRECATED)
- X-Ray cracking requires two logistic stations, one to input oxygen and one to output it. I don't ever use X-Ray cracking, and I don't want to come up with a two plot design to cover the process. If you would like to submit one in the comments, I will add it to the guide.
3 Input Blueprints (DEPRECATED)
- ILS Assembler - This design has one input line feed 10 machines. For casimir crystals, make sure you don't use the longer input line for hydrogen.
Technology Migration (DEPRECATED)
This basic smelter setup is all you need to get you started. Drop of ore in the storage container, pick up Ingots and take them to the next step in the process.
Deprecated Designs
This guide was created by its original author on the Steam Community. Are you the author and want it removed? Request removal.